1 - Legal Reasoning
Copyright
Preface
9 - Contents
Part 1 Introduction
Part 2 Rationality
Part 3 Irrationality
Part 4 Method
16 - Labels
20 - Table of Legislation
23 - Table of Cases
30 - Table of Names
39 - Introduction
Purpose
Legal Tasks
Legal Reasoning
Legal Method
53 - Rationality
Introduction
Being Rational
Being Irrational
58 - Analysing Legal Rules
Introduction
Structure of a Rule
Relationships Between Rules
67 - Logical Reasoning
Introduction
Deduction
Induction
Abduction
Analogy
Probability
Comparison
74 - Deduction
Introduction
Nature
Applying Law
Interpreting Law
Ascertaining Values
Ascertaining Causal Laws
Proving Facts
95 - Induction
Introduction
Nature
Ascertaining Values
Ascertaining Causal Laws
Proving Facts
Proving Facts: Patterns of Behaviour
Proving Facts: Individual Behaviour
Proving Facts: General Behaviour
Common Errors
114 - Abduction
Introduction
Nature
Uses
118 - Analogy
Introduction
Nature
Making Common Law
129 - Probability
Introduction
Measuring Probability
Applying Probability
Assigning Probability
Deriving Probability
Fallacies in Probability
156 - Policy
Introduction
Levels of Policy
Basis of Policy
Nature of Policy
Model for Policy
Derivatives of Policy
175 - Nature of Net Benefit
Introduction
Net Benefit Rule
Changeover Costs and Benefits
Operating Costs and Benefits
Illustration
191 - Measurement of Net Benefit
Introduction
Methods of Measurement
Problem of Measurement
Attempts to Alleviate Problems
Conclusion
201 - Cause
Introduction
Determinism
Science
Nature of Causation
219 - Cause: Explanatory Theories
Introduction
General Theories
Theories of Complex Behaviour
Theories of Legal Compliance
Appendix: Force Field Diagram
270 - Cause: Responding to Uncertainty
Introduction
Expected Value
Review of Legislation
Review of Judicial Decisions
Disjointed Incrementalism
Precautionary Principle
Defensive Design
284 - Effects
Introduction
Continuation of Effects
Operation of Effects
Function of Effects
Prediction of Effects
304 - Values
Introduction
Definition of Values
Deployment of Values
Outline
309 - Classification of Values
Introduction
Deontological and Teleological Values
Absolute and Relative Values
319 - Choice of Values
Introduction
Unity of Values
Diversity of Values
Compromise View
Choice of Values
351 - Social Choice
Introduction
Making Law
Interpreting Law
356 - Social Choice: Making Law
Introduction
Direct Democracy
Representative Democracy
Deliberative Democracy
Social Democracy
Conclusion
374 - Social Choice: Interpreting Law
Introduction
1. Legislative Legitimacy
2. Metademocracy
Deference
Reconstructionism
Pragmatism
Disciplinarianism
3. Judicial Legitimacy
4. Legislative Legitimacy Reinterpreted
411 - Precedent
Introduction
1. Nature of Precedent
Preserving Rules
Preserving Policy
Avoiding Costs
2. Overruling Precedent
424 - Rules
Introduction
Identifying Meanings
Promoting Meanings
430 - Analysing Ambiguity
Introduction
1. Language
2. Ambiguity
Nature of Ambiguity
Prevalence of Ambiguity
Need to Identify Meanings
How to Identify Meanings
3. Limits to Interpretation
General Limits: Language
Specific Limits: Ambiguity
449 - Observing Facts
Introduction
Observation by a Witness
Observation by Equipment
Observation by the Court
Observation by an Institution
457 - Irrationality
Introduction
Psychology
Sociology
Economics
Philosophy
Situational Factors
479 - Legal Method
Introduction
Absence of Method
Need for Method
Nature of Method
490 - Model for Organising Law
Introduction
Macro Analysis
Micro Analysis
494 - Model for Forming Law
Introduction
Step 1: Options
Step 2: Reasons
Step 3: Decision
Justification of the Model
Applications of the Model
516 - Model for Using Law
Introduction
1. Legal Position
2 Syllogism
Major Premise
Minor Premise
Conclusion
3 Model
Structure of the Model
Uses of the Model
537 - Bibliography